When Hiring Creates More Problems. Specialist vs Principal Advice – Part 2 of 3

A couple of weeks ago, the owner of a Sunshine Coast advice firm reached out.

About twelve months ago she hired an adviser to solve her capacity problems.

I had spoken to the preferred candidate back then as part of her selection process.

Nice guy.

I advised he would be good technically, but his role would need to align with her principal advice approach.

He took a drop in remuneration because the role would help him make a bigger difference in his clients’ lives. He was also incentivised by opportunities for equity and building a valuable asset.

Today, the principal is working longer, harder and still frustrated by the dependency she suffers as her cash flows get bigger and tighter.

So what has gone wrong?

The nice guy is good technically.

A solid specialist adviser.

But tone-deaf to the rhythms of principal advice.

The current list of her dependency issues provides all the clues to the difference between principal and specialist skills.

A client whose mother needed aged care, in a hurry.

Another client who lost her partner three months ago and had never paid a bill in forty years of marriage.

Another client whose building business is taking off but his growing family, cost of materials, finding tradies, unpaid bills, and constant cash flow nightmares mean he needs her more than ever.

Another favourite client is gifting money to their kids faster than their best interests can afford.

None of these issues stems from technical complexity.

All of these clients had met the nice guy specialist.

But none of them is working with him as their principal adviser, despite the firm’s numerous attempts to build their confidence in him.

Last week I described specialist advice akin to the motor vehicle industry’s dependency on fossil fuels.

Principal advice runs on electricity, fuelled by what the client values.

Both specialist and principal advice serve the client.

The difference is the types of complexity being served.

Specialist advice recognises one kind.

Principal advice recognises four.

1. Technical complexity.

Superannuation, tax, investments, re-structures, insurance, debt.

The complexity of technical issues clearly matters.

But it’s episodic.

It peaks, gets solved, then settles.

Once the client’s retired, the finances are arranged, the risk is underwritten, the tax is done, the pension is rolling along comfortably, or the investments are in place, the technical complexity reduces.

So does the client’s sense of value for what they’re paying for.

Reliance on technical complexity is akin to my discussions last week about the car industry’s reliance on fossil fuels.

2. Situational complexity.

Short-term, usually two to three years.

The run-up to retirement. Getting parents into aged care. Downsizing once the kids leave home. Getting comfortable in retirement or semi-retirement. Recovering from a divorce. Working through options after a retrenchment or redundancy. Selling a small business.

These complexities not only need technical skills but also project management skills.

Someone trusted to keep the moving parts moving in a client’s objective and subjective best interests.

3. Circumstantial complexity.

Long term, lasting years.

Losing the partner who always looked after the money. Losing the confidence or cognitive health to make objective financial decisions. Running a busy small business. Not wanting to ever worry about money. Managing partnerships, marriages, or ex-marriages that fundamentally disagree on how best to manage finances.

These complexities require not only technical and project management skills, but also patience and people management skills.

This is trusted advice and support needed for the long haul.

4. Behavioural complexity.

The greatest complexity of all.

And it’s lifelong.

Too generous. Too busy. Lacking attention to detail. Too indecisive or reluctant to change. Too timid or cautious. Spending too much. Too sophisticated or precise for their own good. Too anonymous to really know. Too focused on returns rather than a life well lived for themselves and others important to them.

These complexities require all the previous skills plus coaching. As Ralph Waldo Emerson puts it, “Our chief want in life is someone who can make us do what we can”.

I’ve never seen a spreadsheet that can fix or manage a client’s behavioural complexities.

Why this changes the team you build

Review the list again, from top to bottom.

Notice anything?

The further down you go, the more enduring and valuable the advice is.

Technical comes and goes.

Behaviour never leaves.

That’s why principal advice relationships keep charging.

And why specialist relationships run dry.

It’s also why another good technical adviser didn’t address the Sunshine Coast owner’s workloads. After twelve months, she has built a bigger firm. Not a better firm.

She has added more capacity for the technical issues.

Yet every day, her inbox reminds her that only she can address the other three complexities that her clients really value.

And every day there will be more of these.

Principal advice firms don’t build teams of technical experts.

They build expert principal advice teams.

Technical skills, yes.

But equally, project management, people management and coaching skills.

So here’s my question.

How much of your week is on complexities no one else on your team can handle?

What do you reckon?

 

 

Photo Credit: Shutterstock_4229944607